Mother lent daughter over $100,000 without a receipt: Supreme Court explains whether money can be returned
/ 17 November 2026 12:30
4 min to read
The Supreme Court considered the case of the return of more than 100 thousand dollars, which the mother transferred to her daughter to purchase an apartment in Dubai. The parties did not conclude a written loan agreement, but the plaintiff provided bank documents and an audio recording of a conversation in which, according to her, the daughter acknowledged the debt.
This was reported by the “Sudovo-Yurydychna Gazeta” with reference to the Supreme Court’s resolution of November 4, 2026 in case No. 752/16584/23.
How the debt arose
According to the plaintiff, in 2014, the daughter, who was in the United Arab Emirates, asked to borrow money to purchase real estate.
The mother agreed to help on the condition that the daughter return the funds or transfer her housing.
Over several years, the woman transferred $71,280 to her daughter via the international SWIFT system. In addition, in August 2020, according to her, she transferred another $32,000 in cash.
The total amount of funds transferred, according to the mother, was $103,280.
Subsequently, the daughter returned $23,000, but the rest of the money, as the plaintiff claimed, was never returned.
In 2023, the mother went to court with a demand to recover UAH 2.94 million, which at the time of filing the lawsuit corresponded to approximately $80,000.
Why did the courts initially refuse the mother
The Obolonsky District Court of Kyiv refused to satisfy the claim due to the lack of a written loan agreement or receipt.
The court decided that bank transfers in themselves do not confirm the existence of debt obligations.
The Kyiv Court of Appeal left the decision unchanged.
However, the plaintiff insisted that her daughter had repeatedly acknowledged the debt and promised to return the money. In support of this, she provided an audio recording of the conversation.
The defendant’s representative denied that the voice on the recording belonged to her daughter.
What the Supreme Court decided
The Supreme Court emphasized that the absence of a written agreement does not automatically mean that it is impossible to prove the fact of the loan.
According to Article 218 of the Civil Code of Ukraine, the parties may use written evidence, audio and video recordings, and other admissible materials to confirm the agreements.
The court noted that the previous instances did not properly assess the audio recording and did not verify the objections to the defendant’s voice.
At the same time, the Supreme Court did not establish whether the daughter had indeed acknowledged the debt and did not confirm the authenticity of the recording.
The mother’s cassation appeal was partially granted, the decisions of the previous courts were canceled, and the case was sent for retrial to the court of first instance.
Is it possible to repay a debt without a receipt
It follows from the legal position of the Supreme Court that the absence of a receipt does not deprive a person of the opportunity to apply to court with a demand to return the borrowed money.
Evidence may include bank documents, electronic correspondence, audio recordings and other materials that confirm the circumstances of the transfer of funds and the agreement on their return.
However, the fact of transferring money itself does not yet prove that it was a loan, and not a gift or other financial assistance.
The key is the set of evidence that allows us to establish not only the fact of the transfer of funds, but also the obligation to return them.
The final decision on the existence of a debt between mother and daughter must be made by the court during a new consideration of the case.
Without an author